Sunderland
  Portsmouth
Managers
(Sunderland)
(Portsmouth)
Notes
Penalty Shoot Out: McGEADY 1-0; Evans 1-1; CATTERMOLE (saved) 1-1; Pitman 1-2; GOOCH 2-2; Brown 2-3; POWER 3-3; Lowe 3-4; O'NIEN 4-4; Hawkins 4-5.
Goals
Aiden McGeady 38  min
Nathan Thompson 82  min
Jamal Lowe 114  min
Aiden McGeady 119  min