Sunderland
  Middlesbrough
Managers
(Sunderland)
Committee (Managerless)
(Middlesbrough)
Notes
Middlesbrough protested that Sunderland had paid 3 players (Hastings, Monaghan and Richardson). The FA disqualified Sunderland from the FA Cup and awarded the tie to Middlesbrough.
Goals
Dick Wilson 1  min
Jackson Ewbank 29  min
Tam Halliday 46  min
George Millar (OG) 49  min
Arnold Davison 52  min
Tam Halliday 86  min