Statistics are for First Class Competitions only
Sunderland
Manchester City
 
 
Appearances
Apps (Goals)
 
 
Goalscorers
Goals (Apps)
 
 
Manager
Records
P-W-D-L-F-A
 
Charlie Buchan 20   (6)
Arthur Bridgett 16   (7)
Bobby Gurney 16   (9)
George Holley 16   (3)
Len Shackleton 16   (7)
Jack Hedley 14  
Patsy Gallacher 13   (5)
Billy Hogg 12   (4)
Harry Martin 12   (1)
Bill Murray 12  
John O'Shea 12  
Stan Anderson 11   (1)
Jimmy Connor 11   (2)
Billy Farquhar 11   (1)
Alex Hall 11  
Jackie Mordue 11   (2)
Charlie Parker 11   (2)
Jimmy Watson 11  
Phil Bardsley 10   (1)
Raich Carter 10   (3)
Billy Clunas 10   (3)
Frank Cuggy 10  
Jimmy Gemmell 10   (3)
Sebastian Larsson 10   (2)
Gary Rowell 10   (3)
Ned Doig 9  
Adam Johnson 9   (2)
Harry Low 9  
Jack Stelling 9   (1)
Arthur Wright 9   (2)
Fabio Borini 8   (2)
Gordon Chisholm 8   (2)
Stan Cummins 8   (2)
Bert Davis 8   (1)
Fred Hall 8  
Bobby Marshall 8   (4)
Jock McDougall 8   (1)
Tommy Tait 8  
Mick Buckley 7   (2)
Ray Daniel 7   (1)
Billy Ellis 7   (4)
Billy Hughes 7   (3)
Harry Shaw 7  
Colin Todd 7  
Tommy Wright 7   (3)
Len Duns 6  
Dave Halliday 6   (8)
Bobby Kerr 6   (1)
Colin McLatchie 6   (1)
John Poole 6  
Barry Venison 6   (1)
Bobby Best 5  
Wes Brown 5  
Joe Butler 5  
Tom Daykin 5  
Charlie Fleming 5   (2)
Trevor Ford 5   (5)
Bobby Hogg 5   (2)
Kenwynne Jones 5   (2)
Harry Kirtley 5   (1)
Sandy McNab 5   (1)
Harry Ness 5  
Kevin Phillips 5   (3)
Jack Prior 5   (1)
Jack Rodwell 5   (1)
Dennis Tueart 5   (1)
Bob Young 5  
Julio Arca 4  
Ian Atkins 4   (1)
Gary Bennett 4   (1)
Joe Bolton 4  
Harold Buckle 4   (2)
Eddie Burbanks 4   (1)
Ken Chisholm 4   (1)
Billy Eden 4  
Marco Gabbiadini 4   (2)
Jordan Henderson 4   (1)
Joe Kasher 4  
Bobby McKay 4   (3)
Adam McLean 4   (1)
George Mulhall 4   (1)
Jim Oakley 4  
Gary Owers 4  
Niall Quinn 4   (2)
James Raine 4   (1)
Andy Reid 4  
Bryan Robson 4   (1)
Bill Walsh 4  
Dean Whitehead 4   (1)
Gordon Armstrong 3   (1)
Jim Baxter 3  
Darren Bent 3   (1)
Alan Brown 3  
John Cooke 3   (1)
John Craggs 3   (1)
Charlie Crossley 3   (2)
Jermain Defoe 3   (1)
Joe Devine 3  
Ambrose Fogarty 3   (1)
Frank Gray 3  
Kevin Kyle 3   (1)
Bob Lee 3  
Neil Martin 3   (1)
Ally McCoist 3   (1)
John Mensah 3   (1)
Sam Morris 3  
Iain Munro 3  
Ted Purdon 3  
Jackie Robinson 3   (2)
Ronnie Turnbull 3   (1)
Tommy Urwin 3   (1)
Bob Ward 3  
Connor Wickham 3   (3)
Kevin Arnott 2   (1)
Kevin Ball 2  
Ted Bell 2  
Nicklas Bendtner 2   (1)
John Bone 2  
Gary Breen 2  
Arthur Brown 2   (1)
Lee Clark 2   (1)
Tim Coleman 2   (2)
Alf Common 2  
Fred Cooke 2   (1)
Johnny Crossan 2   (3)
Peter Davenport 2   (1)
Dickie Davis 2   (2)
Eric Gates 2   (1)
Vic Halom 2   (1)
John Hawley 2   (3)
Mick Horswill 2   (1)
Don Hutchison 2   (1)
John Kay 2  
Sam Kemp 2   (1)
Jim Leslie 2   (1)
Joe McGhie 2  
Tom Naisby 2  
John Parke 2  
Alex Rae 2  
Don Revie 2   (1)
Danny Rose 2  
Percy Saunders 2   (1)
Joe Shaw 2   (1)
Jon Stead 2  
Colin West 2  
Sam Aiston 1  
Adam Allan 1  
Phil Babb 1  
Joe Baker 1  
Tommy Becton 1   (1)
Bob Bolder 1  
Tom Brown 1  
John Cowell 1   (2)
Rory Delap 1  
Barry Dunn 1  
Andy Gray 1  
Tom Hall 1  
Ian Harte 1  
Mel Holden 1  
Harry Hood 1  
Dong-Won Ji 1   (1)
Bob Kelly 1   (1)
Andy Kerr 1  
Don Kichenbrand 1   (1)
Joe Lane 1  
Billy Marsden 1   (1)
Bobby Park 1  
Reg Pearce 1  
Mart Poom 1  
Bill Read 1   (2)
Ted Robson 1  
Eric Roy 1  
Louis Saha 1  
Colin Symm 1  
Ola Toivonen 1   (1)
Ray Train 1  
Walter Watkins 1   (1)
Andy Welsh 1  
Tom Wylie 1   (1)
Benny Yorston 1   (1)
John Young 1  
 
Bobby Gurney 9   (16)
Dave Halliday 8   (6)
Arthur Bridgett 7   (16)
Len Shackleton 7   (16)
Charlie Buchan 6   (20)
Trevor Ford 5   (5)
Patsy Gallacher 5   (13)
Billy Ellis 4   (7)
Bobby Marshall 4   (8)
Billy Hogg 4   (12)
Johnny Crossan 3   (2)
John Hawley 3   (2)
Connor Wickham 3   (3)
Bobby McKay 3   (4)
Kevin Phillips 3   (5)
Billy Hughes 3   (7)
Tommy Wright 3   (7)
Raich Carter 3   (10)
Billy Clunas 3   (10)
Jimmy Gemmell 3   (10)
Gary Rowell 3   (10)
George Holley 3   (16)
John Cowell 2   (1)
Bill Read 2   (1)
Tim Coleman 2   (2)
Dickie Davis 2   (2)
Charlie Crossley 2   (3)
Jackie Robinson 2   (3)
Harold Buckle 2   (4)
Marco Gabbiadini 2   (4)
Niall Quinn 2   (4)
Charlie Fleming 2   (5)
Bobby Hogg 2   (5)
Kenwynne Jones 2   (5)
Mick Buckley 2   (7)
Fabio Borini 2   (8)
Gordon Chisholm 2   (8)
Stan Cummins 2   (8)
Adam Johnson 2   (9)
Arthur Wright 2   (9)
Sebastian Larsson 2   (10)
Jimmy Connor 2   (11)
Jackie Mordue 2   (11)
Charlie Parker 2   (11)
Tommy Becton 1   (1)
Dong-Won Ji 1   (1)
Bob Kelly 1   (1)
Don Kichenbrand 1   (1)
Billy Marsden 1   (1)
Ola Toivonen 1   (1)
Walter Watkins 1   (1)
Tom Wylie 1   (1)
Benny Yorston 1   (1)
Kevin Arnott 1   (2)
Nicklas Bendtner 1   (2)
Arthur Brown 1   (2)
Lee Clark 1   (2)
Fred Cooke 1   (2)
Peter Davenport 1   (2)
Eric Gates 1   (2)
Vic Halom 1   (2)
Mick Horswill 1   (2)
Don Hutchison 1   (2)
Sam Kemp 1   (2)
Jim Leslie 1   (2)
Don Revie 1   (2)
Percy Saunders 1   (2)
Joe Shaw 1   (2)
Gordon Armstrong 1   (3)
Darren Bent 1   (3)
John Cooke 1   (3)
John Craggs 1   (3)
Jermain Defoe 1   (3)
Ambrose Fogarty 1   (3)
Kevin Kyle 1   (3)
Neil Martin 1   (3)
Ally McCoist 1   (3)
John Mensah 1   (3)
Ronnie Turnbull 1   (3)
Tommy Urwin 1   (3)
Ian Atkins 1   (4)
Gary Bennett 1   (4)
Eddie Burbanks 1   (4)
Ken Chisholm 1   (4)
Jordan Henderson 1   (4)
Adam McLean 1   (4)
George Mulhall 1   (4)
James Raine 1   (4)
Bryan Robson 1   (4)
Dean Whitehead 1   (4)
Harry Kirtley 1   (5)
Sandy McNab 1   (5)
Jack Prior 1   (5)
Jack Rodwell 1   (5)
Dennis Tueart 1   (5)
Bobby Kerr 1   (6)
Colin McLatchie 1   (6)
Barry Venison 1   (6)
Ray Daniel 1   (7)
Bert Davis 1   (8)
Jock McDougall 1   (8)
Jack Stelling 1   (9)
Phil Bardsley 1   (10)
Stan Anderson 1   (11)
Billy Farquhar 1   (11)
Harry Martin 1   (12)
 
Robert Kyle 34   13   5   16   50   58
Johnny Cochrane 21   9   5   7   41   40
Bill Murray 19   4   3   12   30   39
Alex Mackie 11   4   3   4   18   15
Alan Brown 9   4   0   5   9   14
Alan Durban 6   3   2   1   10   8
Gustavo Poyet 5   1   1   3   7   12
Ken Knighton 4   3   1   0   8   1
Peter Reid 4   3   0   1   7   5
Martin O'Neill 4   2   1   1   5   6
Steve Bruce 4   1   1   2   5   10
Denis Smith 4   0   2   2   6   9
Ian McColl 3   2   0   1   2   1
Bob Stokoe 3   1   1   1   5   5
Roy Keane 3   0   0   3   1   6
Mick McCarthy 3   0   0   3   2   7
Sam Allardyce 2   0   0   2   1   5
David Moyes 2   0   0   2   1   4
Lawrie McMenemy 1   0   1   0   0   0
Jimmy Adamson 1   0   0   1   0   1
Dick Advocaat 1   0   0   1   1   4
Ricky Sbragia 1   0   0   1   0   1
Howard Wilkinson 1   0   0   1   0   3
 
Eric Brook 20   (9)
Bobby Marshall 18   (6)
Ernie Toseland 18   (2)
Sam Cowan 17  
Eli Fletcher 17  
Roy Clarke 16   (6)
Joe Corrigan 16  
Tommy Johnson 15   (6)
Walter Smith 14  
Frank Swift 14  
Yaya Toure 14   (4)
Joe Hart 13  
Aleksandar Kolarov 13   (2)
Fred Tilson 13   (2)
Dave Ewing 12  
Roy Paul 12  
David Silva 12   (1)
Sergio Aguero 11   (7)
Jackie Bray 11  
Billy Dale 11  
Billy Meredith 11   (1)
Pablo Zabaleta 11   (1)
Horace Barnes 10   (6)
Tommy Browell 10   (6)
Alan Oakes 10   (2)
Paul Power 10  
Micah Richards 10   (1)
Colin Bell 9   (2)
Tony Book 9  
Matt Busby 9  
Mike Doyle 9  
Bill Eadie 9   (1)
Dennis Tueart 9   (2)
Sam Barkas 8  
Tommy Caton 8   (1)
George Dorsett 8   (1)
Fernandinho 8   (1)
Asa Hartford 8   (1)
Tom Holford 8   (1)
Roy Little 8  
James Milner 8   (1)
Ray Ranson 8  
Kevin Reeves 8   (2)
Don Revie 8   (4)
Frank Roberts 8   (1)
Irvine Thornley 8   (6)
Neil Young 8   (1)
Ken Barnes 7  
James Buchan 7   (1)
Joe Hayes 7   (6)
Tommy Hynds 7   (1)
Billy Murphy 7   (6)
Jesus Navas 7   (1)
Nicky Reid 7  
Mike Summerbee 7   (1)
Carlos Tevez 7   (2)
Sandy Turnbull 7   (7)
George Wynn 7   (2)
Billy Austin 6   (3)
Matt Barrass 6   (2)
Frank Booth 6   (1)
Joe Dorsett 6   (1)
Edin Dzeko 6  
Joe Fagan 6  
Paddy Fagan 6   (1)
Jimmy Heale 6   (1)
Alex Herd 6   (1)
Fred Howard 6   (3)
Di Jones 6  
Francis Lee 6   (4)
Samir Nasri 6   (2)
Charlie Williams 6   (1)
Kevin Bond 5  
Peter Doherty 5   (5)
Billy Gillespie 5   (3)
Mickey Hamill 5   (1)
Johnny Hart 5   (6)
George Hicks 5   (2)
Stephen Ireland 5   (2)
Sun Jihai 5   (1)
Adam Johnson 5   (2)
Billy McAdams 5   (3)
Frank Norgrove 5   (1)
Raheem Sterling 5   (2)
George Stewart 5   (2)
Andy Black 4   (2)
Kevin De Bruyne 4   (2)
Harry Dowd 4  
Elano 4   (1)
Sid Hoad 4  
Jackie Oakes 4   (1)
Jimmy Ross 4  
Cliff Sear 4  
Kolo Toure 4  
Darius Vassell 4   (2)
David White 4   (4)
Mario Balotelli 3   (2)
Craig Bellamy 3   (1)
David Cross 3   (2)
Jack Dyson 3   (2)
Shay Given 3  
Bob Grieve 3   (2)
Dave Halliday 3   (3)
Ted Hanney 3  
Stevan Jovetic 3   (2)
Bobby Moffatt 3   (1)
Dennis Westcott 3   (2)
John Williamson 3   (2)
Jack Allen 2  
Harry Anders 2   (1)
Jimmy Bannister 2   (1)
Ivor Broadis 2   (2)
Syd Cann 2  
R. Dearden 2  
Fernando 2  
Marc Vivien Foe 2   (3)
Nigel Gleghorn 2   (1)
Shaun Goater 2   (1)
Matt Gray 2  
Alf-Inge Haaland 2   (1)
Percy Hill 2  
Andy Hinchcliffe 2   (1)
Stan Horne 2  
Jo 2  
Brian Kidd 2  
Frank Lampard 2   (1)
Andy May 2  
Eddie McMorran 2   (1)
Neil McNab 2  
Ian Mellor 2  
Nolito 2  
Niall Quinn 2   (2)
Joe Reid 2   (1)
Jack Rigby 2  
Mick Robinson 2   (1)
Joe Rogers 2  
Uwe Rosler 2  
Joe Royle 2   (1)
Roque Santa Cruz 2   (2)
Sid Scott 2  
Trevor Sinclair 2   (1)
Alex Steel 2  
Kit Symons 2  
Tommy Tait 2   (1)
Tony Towers 2   (1)
Patrick Viera 2   (1)
Fred Bevan 1  
Ian Bishop 1  
Wilfried Bony 1   (1)
Ian Bowyer 1   (2)
Phil Boyer 1  
Joe Cartwright 1   (1)
Andy Cole 1  
Tony Coton 1  
Ian Davies 1  
Joe Davies 1  
Ron Dellow 1  
S. Eyres 1   (1)
Robbie Fowler 1   (1)
Trevor Francis 1   (2)
Gerry Gow 1  
Bert Gray 1  
Tony Henry 1  
Andy Hill 1  
Jimmy Hindmarsh 1   (1)
Dick Jones 1  
John McLeod 1   (1)
Trevor Morley 1   (1)
Billy Murray 1   (1)
Eric Nixon 1  
Alan Ogley 1  
Willie Orr 1  
Billy Owen 1  
Bobby Owen 1  
Gary Owen 1  
Ron Powell 1  
Jose Pozo 1  
Peter Reid 1  
Bill Ridding 1   (1)
Robinho 1  
David Ross 1  
Harry Rowley 1   (2)
John Ryan 1  
Georgios Samaras 1   (2)
Leroy Sane 1   (1)
Ronnie Turnbull 1   (1)
Len Wall 1  
Paulo Wanchope 1   (3)
Mark Ward 1  
Jack Warner 1   (1)
Ken Whitfield 1   (1)
James Whittaker 1   (1)
Alf Wood 1  
 
Eric Brook 9   (20)
Sandy Turnbull 7   (7)
Sergio Aguero 7   (11)
Johnny Hart 6   (5)
Joe Hayes 6   (7)
Billy Murphy 6   (7)
Irvine Thornley 6   (8)
Horace Barnes 6   (10)
Tommy Browell 6   (10)
Tommy Johnson 6   (15)
Roy Clarke 6   (16)
Bobby Marshall 6   (18)
Peter Doherty 5   (5)
David White 4   (4)
Francis Lee 4   (6)
Don Revie 4   (8)
Yaya Toure 4   (14)
Paulo Wanchope 3   (1)
Marc Vivien Foe 3   (2)
Dave Halliday 3   (3)
Billy Gillespie 3   (5)
Billy McAdams 3   (5)
Billy Austin 3   (6)
Fred Howard 3   (6)
Ian Bowyer 2   (1)
Trevor Francis 2   (1)
Harry Rowley 2   (1)
Georgios Samaras 2   (1)
Ivor Broadis 2   (2)
Niall Quinn 2   (2)
Roque Santa Cruz 2   (2)
Mario Balotelli 2   (3)
David Cross 2   (3)
Jack Dyson 2   (3)
Bob Grieve 2   (3)
Stevan Jovetic 2   (3)
Dennis Westcott 2   (3)
John Williamson 2   (3)
Andy Black 2   (4)
Kevin De Bruyne 2   (4)
Darius Vassell 2   (4)
George Hicks 2   (5)
Stephen Ireland 2   (5)
Adam Johnson 2   (5)
Raheem Sterling 2   (5)
George Stewart 2   (5)
Matt Barrass 2   (6)
Samir Nasri 2   (6)
Carlos Tevez 2   (7)
George Wynn 2   (7)
Kevin Reeves 2   (8)
Colin Bell 2   (9)
Dennis Tueart 2   (9)
Alan Oakes 2   (10)
Aleksandar Kolarov 2   (13)
Fred Tilson 2   (13)
Ernie Toseland 2   (18)
Wilfried Bony 1   (1)
Joe Cartwright 1   (1)
S. Eyres 1   (1)
Robbie Fowler 1   (1)
Jimmy Hindmarsh 1   (1)
John McLeod 1   (1)
Trevor Morley 1   (1)
Billy Murray 1   (1)
Bill Ridding 1   (1)
Leroy Sane 1   (1)
Ronnie Turnbull 1   (1)
Jack Warner 1   (1)
Ken Whitfield 1   (1)
James Whittaker 1   (1)
Harry Anders 1   (2)
Jimmy Bannister 1   (2)
Nigel Gleghorn 1   (2)
Shaun Goater 1   (2)
Alf-Inge Haaland 1   (2)
Andy Hinchcliffe 1   (2)
Frank Lampard 1   (2)
Eddie McMorran 1   (2)
Joe Reid 1   (2)
Mick Robinson 1   (2)
Joe Royle 1   (2)
Trevor Sinclair 1   (2)
Tommy Tait 1   (2)
Tony Towers 1   (2)
Patrick Viera 1   (2)
Craig Bellamy 1   (3)
Bobby Moffatt 1   (3)
Elano 1   (4)
Jackie Oakes 1   (4)
Mickey Hamill 1   (5)
Sun Jihai 1   (5)
Frank Norgrove 1   (5)
Frank Booth 1   (6)
Joe Dorsett 1   (6)
Paddy Fagan 1   (6)
Jimmy Heale 1   (6)
Alex Herd 1   (6)
Charlie Williams 1   (6)
James Buchan 1   (7)
Tommy Hynds 1   (7)
Jesus Navas 1   (7)
Mike Summerbee 1   (7)
Tommy Caton 1   (8)
George Dorsett 1   (8)
Fernandinho 1   (8)
Asa Hartford 1   (8)
Tom Holford 1   (8)
James Milner 1   (8)
Frank Roberts 1   (8)
Neil Young 1   (8)
Bill Eadie 1   (9)
Micah Richards 1   (10)
Billy Meredith 1   (11)
Pablo Zabaleta 1   (11)
David Silva 1   (12)
 
Ernest Mangnall 17   10   1   6   26   18
Les McDowall 15   9   2   4   34   27
Wilf Wild 13   4   2   7   19   22
Harry Newbould 10   3   4   3   15   16
Peter Hodge 9   4   3   2   23   20
Manuel Pellegrini 8   6   1   1   21   9
Joe Mercer 8   5   0   3   11   3
Tom Maley 7   4   2   1   16   9
Roberto Mancini 7   2   2   3   12   7
John Bond 6   1   2   3   6   9
Sam Ormerod 6   1   1   4   4   12
Malcolm Allison 5   0   2   3   4   11
Jock Thomson 4   2   1   1   4   5
Mark Hughes 3   3   0   0   8   3
David Ashworth 3   1   0   2   7   7
Tony Book 2   2   0   0   3   0
Sven Goran Eriksson 2   2   0   0   3   1
Pep Guardiola 2   2   0   0   4   1
Kevin Keegan 2   2   0   0   6   0
Stuart Pearce 2   2   0   0   4   2
Mel Machin 2   1   1   0   5   3
Joe Royle 2   1   0   1   4   3
Frank Clark 2   0   0   2   1   4
George Poyser 2   0   0   2   0   5
Committee (Managerless) 1   1   0   0   2   1
Sam Cowan 1   1   0   0   3   0
Peter Reid 1   1   0   0   3   2
Howard Kendall 1   0   1   0   1   1
Billy McNeill 1   0   1   0   0   0
Albert Alexander 1   0   0   1   3   5
John Benson 1   0   0   1   2   3