Sunderland
  Morpeth Harriers
Managers
(Sunderland)
?
(Morpeth Harriers)
Notes
The FA ordered the tie to be replayed as Sunderland's full-back Ford had not been registered in time for the game. If Morpeth had known and protested Sunderland would have been expelled from the competition.
Goals
George Monaghan 30  min
John Waterston 31  min
George Monaghan ?  min
Reuben Smith ?  min
George Monaghan ?  min
T. Crackett ?  min