Sunderland
  Bolton Wanderers
Managers
(Sunderland)
(Bolton Wanderers)
Notes
This was the first season in which the penalty kicks could be awarded, and John Auld converted Sunderland's first ever award in a competitive match. [Note: most reference books have credited the penalty to Hughie Wilson, but newspaper reports do not bear this out; Auld is mentioned in almost all reports in which the penalty taker is actually named.]
Goals
Johnny Campbell 2  min
Jack McNee 4  min
David McFetteridge 7  min
Jimmy Cassidy 33  min
Jimmy Cassidy 35  min
Jimmy Millar 44  min
John Auld (pen) 75  min