Sunderland
  Gainsborough Trinity
Managers
(Sunderland)
?
(Gainsborough Trinity)
Notes
Gainsborough decided to host their 'home' replay at Roker Park. It was reported that they were persuaded to do this by Sunderland paying them £300, with Sunderland keeping all the receipts. This back-fired somewhat, as the official receipts were only £244.
Goals
Arthur Bridgett 3  min
Norman Brown 32  min
George Holley 69  min