1985-86Tuesday, 1 October 1985Full Members Cup1st Round, 2nd LegRoker Park 11,571

Sunderland(1) 2Grimsby Town(1) 1After extra time; score at 90 minutes: 2 - 1Aggregate score 4 - 4; Sunderland won 3 - 2 on penaltiesBOLDER, BobBURLEY, GeorgeKENNEDY, AlanDANIEL, PeterBENNETT, GaryELLIOTT, ShaunGRAY, FrankVENISON, BarrySWINDLEHURST, DaveGATES, Eric1ATKINSON, Paul Substitutes WALKER, Clive(Not Used)HODGSON, David1(Not Used)Sunderland's successful penalty scorers were: Kennedy, Gates and Hodgson.