1911-12Wednesday, 7 February 1912Football Association Challenge Cup2nd Round, ReplayRoker Park 30,000 (Approximate)
Sunderland(0) 1Crystal Palace(0) 0After extra time; score at 90 minutes: 0 - 0SCOTT, WalterTROUGHEAR, BillyMILTON, AlbertCUGGY, FrankTHOMSON, Charlie B.CRINGAN, BillyMORDUE, JackieBUCHAN, CharlieLOW, Harry
1HOLLEY, GeorgeBRIDGETT, Arthur