1911-12Saturday, 13 January 1912Football Association Challenge Cup1st RoundRoker Park 20,000 (Approximate)
Sunderland(2) 3Plymouth Argyle(1) 1SCOTT, WalterTROUGHEAR, BillyMILTON, AlbertCUGGY, FrankTHOMSON, Charlie B.CRINGAN, BillyMORDUE, Jackie
2(1p)BUCHAN, CharlieYOUNG, JohnHOLLEY, GeorgeBRIDGETT, Arthur1