1998-99Wednesday, 11 November 1998Worthington Cup4th RoundGoodison Park 28,132
Everton(0) 1Sunderland(1) 1After extra time; score at 90 minutes: 1 - 1Sunderland won 5 - 4 on penaltiesSORENSEN, ThomasMAKIN, ChrisSCOTT, MartinTHIRLWELL, PaulMELVILLE, AndyBUTLER, PaulSMITH, MartinWILLIAMS, DarrenQUINN, NiallBRIDGES, Michael1JOHNSTON, Allan Substitutes MARRIOTT, Andy(Not Used)CRADDOCK, Jody(for BUTLER, Paul)CLARK, Lee(for THIRLWELL, Paul)WAINWRIGHT, Neil(Not Used)PROCTOR, Michael(for BRIDGES, Michael)Sunderland's successful penalty scorers were: Scott, Smith, Quinn, Johnston and Clark. Makin was the only Sunderland player to miss.