1889 F St. Mirren H L 1 - 2 c. 6,000 Saturday

1895 Lge DIV 1 Blackburn Rovers A W 4 - 2 c. 10,000 Saturday

1901 Lge DIV 1 Bury A L 0 - 1 c. 13,000 Saturday

1907 Lge DIV 1 Sheffield United A L 3 - 5 c. 12,000 Saturday

1912 Lge DIV 1 Notts. County H W 4 - 0 c. 12,000 Saturday

1929 Lge DIV 1 Sheffield United A L 2 - 4 19,025 Saturday

1935 Lge DIV 1 Sheffield Wednesday H W 5 - 1 32,890 Saturday

1946 Lge DIV 1 Manchester United A W 3 - 0 48,388 Saturday

1957 Lge DIV 1 Sheffield Wednesday A D 3 - 3 22,618 Saturday

1960 FLC 2 Brentford A L 3 - 4 10,400 Wednesday

1963 Lge DIV 2 Middlesbrough A L 0 - 2 43,616 Saturday

1964 FLC 3 Blackpool H W 4 - 1 20,540 Monday

1968 Lge DIV 1 Coventry City H W 3 - 0 21,981 Saturday

1974 Lge DIV 2 Hull City A L 1 - 3 15,010 Saturday

1983 FLC 2L2 Cambridge United H W 4 - 3 9,059 Wednesday

Sunderland won 7 - 5 on aggregate

1985 Lge DIV 2 Norwich City H L 0 - 2 17,908 Saturday

1991 Lge DIV 2 Bristol Rovers H D 1 - 1 14,746 Saturday

1993 FLC 3 Aston Villa H L 1 - 4 23,692 Tuesday

1996 Lge PREM Aston Villa H W 1 - 0 21,059 Saturday

2016 FLC 4 Southampton A L 0 - 1 21,460 Wednesday

2019 Lge LGE 1 Shrewsbury Town A L 0 - 1 8,117 Saturday

2021 FLC 4 Queen's Park Rangers A D 0 - 0 15,372 Tuesday

Sunderland won 3 - 1 on penalties